There are some problems involved in dealing with the domainer crowd. I don't know if it's unique, but in my experience, they are more difficult to do business with than normal people.
1. If you don't approach them in the right way, they may be offended. Like the Soup Nazi, even if you're willing to pay more than their ask price, you may not get the chance to negotiate with them. And, they all have their own set "rules" on how negotiations for domains should commence. You might be able to find out some details about them by using the methods others have used.
2. There is no real standard means of valuing domains. You think it's difficult to value a website? Websites are as easy as cake compared to domains. The problem is, each domain is unique by nature, and you can try to compare it to recent sales but there is a significant percentage of domainers who have their own valuation ideas and if your ideas of valuation are not in sync with theirs, then it's "No Soup For You!"
3. Sometimes it's easier to use a marketplace like Sedo.com for the negotiations. I'd check to see if the domain is listed anywhere first, and if it is listed I'd put in an offer through their system. It's not perfect, but often a seller will set a minimum offer for you so you'll at least get a hint at where they think the sale price should end up. I've used Sedo for quite a few of my buys.
4. Always have an alternative. The most powerful tool in your tool chest in a negotiations is the ability to walk away from the table if the terms aren't to your liking. This domain may be your first choice, but you should do your best to have a strong second choice in case things aren't going the way you like. As in all negotiations, if the other party thinks they have you over a barrel, then you're either going to get screwed or you're going to walk away. Occasionally, walking away can shake loose a better deal for you.
good luck!


Reply With Quote


Bookmarks